How to prove square root of 2 is irrational (Constructive Approach)

In our previous post, we discussed how to prove that the square root of 2 is irrational, using a proof by contradiction.

There is a less well-known proof that is a direct constructive approach to proving that the square root of 2 is irrational!

We consider an arbitrary rational number \displaystyle\frac{a}{b}, and show that the difference between \sqrt{2} and \displaystyle\frac{a}{b} cannot be zero. Hence, the square root of 2 cannot be rational.

Firstly, we have:


\displaystyle =|\frac{\sqrt{2}b-a}{b}|\times \frac{\sqrt{2}b+a}{\sqrt{2}b+a}     (Rationalizing the numerator)

\displaystyle =\frac{|2b^2-a^2|}{\sqrt{2}b^2+ab}

\displaystyle =\boxed{\frac{|2b^2-a^2|}{b(\sqrt{2}b+a)}}

Now, we analyse the numerator. We can write a=2^\alpha\cdot x,

b=2^\beta\cdot y, where x,y are odd.

Then 2b^2=2^{2\beta +1}\cdot y^2,

a^2=2^{2\alpha}\cdot x^2.

Since the largest power of two dividing 2b^2 is an odd power, whilst for a^2 the largest power of two dividing it is an even power, 2b^2 and a^2 cannot be the same number. Hence we have |2b^2-a^2|\geq 1.

Now, we analyse the denominator. Firstly, we can consider just the rationals \displaystyle \frac{a}{b}\leq 3-\sqrt{2}\approx 1.59. Because if \frac{a}{b}>1.59, it is clear that \frac{a}{b} is not going to be \sqrt{2}\approx 1.41.

Rearranging, we have: \displaystyle \sqrt{2}+\frac{a}{b}\leq 3.

Multiplying throughout by b, \sqrt{2}b+a\leq 3b.

Going back to the original equation (boxed), we can conclude that:


We have shown constructively that \sqrt{2} is not a rational number!



Featured book:

Becoming a Problem Solving Genius: A Handbook of Math Strategies

Every math student needs a tool belt of problem solving strategies to call upon when solving word problems. In addition to many traditional strategies, this book includes new techniques such as Think 1, the 2-10 method, and others developed by math educator Ed Zaccaro. Each unit contains problems at five levels of difficulty to meet the needs of not only the average math student, but also the highly gifted. Answer key and detailed solutions are included. Grades 4-12